Head to Head
| USA - MLS | 2023/07/08 23:30 | Columbus Crew v New York City FC | D | 1-1 |
| USA - MLS | 2023/06/17 19:30 | New York City FC v Columbus Crew | D | 1-1 |
| USA - MLS | 2022/08/06 23:30 | Columbus Crew v New York City FC | L | 3-2 |
| USA - MLS | 2022/05/14 23:00 | New York City FC v Columbus Crew | W | 2-0 |
| USA - MLS | 2021/07/30 23:30 | New York City FC v Columbus Crew | W | 4-1 |
| USA - MLS | 2021/07/17 23:30 | Columbus Crew v New York City FC | L | 2-1 |
| USA - MLS | 2021/05/22 23:30 | New York City FC v Columbus Crew | L | 1-2 |
| USA - MLS | 2020/10/18 22:00 | Columbus Crew v New York City FC | L | 3-1 |
Home History
| USA - MLS | 2024/05/18 23:30 | New York City FC v New York Red Bulls | W | 2-1 |
| USA - MLS | 2024/05/15 23:30 | Philadelphia Union v New York City FC | W | 1-2 |
| USA - MLS | 2024/05/11 23:30 | Toronto FC v New York City FC | W | 2-3 |
| USA - MLS | 2024/05/05 20:00 | New York City FC v Colorado Rapids | L | 0-2 |
| USA - MLS | 2024/04/27 23:30 | New York City FC v Charlotte FC | W | 2-1 |
| USA - MLS | 2024/04/20 23:30 | New York City FC v DC United | W | 2-0 |
| USA - MLS | 2024/04/13 23:30 | New York City FC v New England Revolution | W | 2-0 |
| USA - MLS | 2024/04/06 23:30 | New York City FC v Atlanta United | D | 1-1 |
Away History
| USA - MLS | 2024/05/15 23:30 | CF Montreal v Columbus Crew | W | 1-3 |
| USA - MLS | 2024/05/11 23:45 | Columbus Crew v FC Cincinnati | L | 1-2 |
| CONCACAF - Coppa dei Campioni | 2024/05/02 02:15 | Monterrey v Columbus Crew | W | 1-3 |
| USA - MLS | 2024/04/27 23:30 | Columbus Crew v CF Montreal | D | 0-0 |
| CONCACAF - Coppa dei Campioni | 2024/04/25 00:15 | Columbus Crew v Monterrey | W | 2-1 |
| USA - MLS | 2024/04/20 23:30 | Columbus Crew v Portland Timbers | D | 2-2 |
| USA - MLS | 2024/04/14 01:30 | Real Salt Lake v Columbus Crew | D | 0-0 |
| CONCACAF - Coppa dei Campioni | 2024/04/10 00:45 | Tigres UANL v Columbus Crew | W | 4-5 |